eat

The Long-Run Danger of the Keto Diet

Nov 20, 2026 marcus antebi 3 min read
The Long-Run Danger of the Keto Diet

The keto diet is simple to explain. You cut out almost all carbohydrates, meaning bread, pasta, rice, fruit, beans and sugar, and you eat mostly fat and protein instead. Without carbs to burn, the body switches fuel and starts running on fat, turning it into something called ketones. People lose weight fast, and that quick result is a big part of why keto got so popular.

Keto is not new. It has been around since the 1920s as a treatment for epilepsy, and for some medical conditions, under a doctor's care, it still has a real place. In the short run, it can also help. A 2023 review covering 17 meta-analyses of 68 trials found that keto diets can improve triglycerides, body weight and blood sugar in adults with overweight or obesity. The trouble starts when keto stops being a short-term tool and becomes a way of life.

We don't know what years of keto do to a person

The honest truth is that nobody has studied keto long enough to call it safe. Compared with the Mediterranean or DASH diets, keto is highly restrictive, hard to keep up, and lacks long-term data. Most keto studies run for weeks or months, not decades. When a diet throws out a whole food group, we should want proof before living on it for years.

What the warning signs show

Your heart. The biggest concern is cholesterol. That same 2023 review found a significant increase in LDL cholesterol, the kind that clogs arteries. A diet can help you lose weight this year and still be quietly hurting your heart over the next twenty.

Your kidneys. In a review of 2,795 people on keto diets, 7.9 percent of the adults developed kidney stones. Eating lots of animal protein makes urine more acidic, and that helps stones form.

Your gut. When you cut carbs, you also cut most of your fiber, because fiber comes from plants. Fiber feeds the friendly bacteria in your gut and keeps things moving. Other long-term side effects of keto include constipation, bloating, diarrhea, and a higher risk of kidney stones.

Your muscles. Small studies suggest people on keto lose muscle even when they keep up resistance training. As we age, muscle is one of the most important things we have.

It matters what you replace the carbs with

The largest warning comes from research that followed hundreds of thousands of people over many years. A meta-analysis of 432,179 people found that both very low carbohydrate diets and very high carbohydrate diets carried greater risk of death than moderate intake. From age 50, people who ate a moderate amount of carbohydrates lived on average four years longer than those who ate very few.

But the most important finding was this. Mortality went up when carbohydrates were replaced with animal fat or protein, and went down when the replacements were plant-based. An older Harvard study saw the same pattern. A low-carb diet built on animal foods was linked to higher death rates in both men and women, while a low-carb diet built on vegetable sources was linked to lower death rates.

Most people doing keto in America are not eating avocados, nuts and olive oil. They are eating bacon, cheese, butter and steak. That is exactly the version the research warns about.

A note on fairness

The science is not completely settled. Some studies show cholesterol going down on keto rather than up, and researchers are still arguing. These large long-term studies show links, not proof, and they depend on people reporting their own diets. Still, when you put it all together, nothing suggests that living on meat and fat for decades is a safe bet.

What it means for us

Carbohydrates are not the enemy. The problem is junk carbs: white sugar, white flour, soda, and processed snacks. Fruit, vegetables, beans, whole grains, nuts and seeds are carbohydrates too, and they are some of the healthiest foods on Earth. A diet that cuts them out to get rid of the junk throws away the medicine with the poison.

If keto helped you lose weight, that's real. But for the long run, the evidence points somewhere simpler. Eat mostly plants, eat whole foods, cut the processed junk, and don't build your life around a plate of meat. If you have a medical condition, talk with your doctor before making big changes.

← more eat

talk back

free advicefrom our team of high school throw-outs

tap into our thousands of self-help blogs,

ask anything.