From Juice Press to goodsugar: Store Two Is Coming
Hello, I’m Marcus, the founder of goodsugar.
Before I tell you where we’re going, I want to tell you a little about where I’ve been.
From approximately 1995 to 2002, I was running my own skydiving business. I sold parachuting equipment through mail order, operated a retail store at the drop zone in Gardiner, New York, and produced training and educational films about skydiving. It was an adventure, to say the least.
Around 2003, I sold the business and moved back to New York City full-time.
My father had an opportunity in our family’s art and antiques business. A retail space had become available on 55th Street, and he qwanted me to come work with him.
So I did.
It was a wonderful experience because I got to spend more time with my pops, and we made money together. But the art and antiques industry was incredibly boring to me. I had no passion for it whatsoever.
After a few years of saving money, I finally got up the nerve to tell my father, “Dad, I’m going into the juice business.”
I invited him to join me, but he wanted absolutely nothing to do with the food industry. Period.
By 2009, I was working on the business plan for what would eventually become Juice Press. I had lots of ideas, plenty of enthusiasm, and a good amount of insecurity about doing it by myself.
So I hesitated.
Then one day, a phenomenal little storefront became available on East 1st Street in Manhattan. It was a location I knew very well.
I have to confess something about my original motivation for wanting that store.
I was across the street in the children’s park, playing with my daughter Luna, when I looked up and noticed the “For Rent” sign.
My first subconscious thought wasn’t about changing the way people eat or building a giant business.
It was, “If I have that store, I could make lots of friends.”
That’s the truth.
I just wanted to be part of that neighborhood. I wanted a place where people would come in, hang out, get to know each other, and maybe buy something healthy along the way.
So I contacted the landlord, negotiated a lease, and got the store.
Then I approached a friend who owned a health food store around the corner.
“You want to join me?”
“Sure.”
He kicked in some money.
A couple of months into construction, another old friend happened to stick his head into the store.
“You want to get in?”
“Yes.”
He kicked in some money, too.
And just like that, we were a trio.
We fought tooth and nail over practically everything, but I maintained control because this was my baby.
With the help of my good friend Richard Murphy, I built that little store from the floorboards to the tiles. I was involved in just about every detail.
Somewhere around April 2010, we opened the doors.
And the journey began.
I could tell you it was a roller coaster ride, but for me, it was actually pretty smooth sailing. There were challenges, of course, but we were building something that people genuinely wanted.
By the time I sold my interest in Juice Press, we had reached 85 stores.
I’m happy I got out exactly when I did.
And I didn’t waste a moment thinking about what I wanted to do next.
I knew I wanted to build another business in the same industry, but this time I wanted to do it according to my own principles, with the benefit of everything I had learned.
I already had dozens of ideas organized in my project management software. I had established the brand name, started working on trademarks, and developed concepts for everything from food products to packaging.
Then COVID happened.
Suddenly, opening a store wasn’t such an urgent priority.
But there was an enormous amount of work to do, and I realized that I had been handed something incredibly valuable: time.
Time to create without the pressure of a construction deadline. Time to work on every single detail instead of rushing to make decisions while contractors were waiting and rent was coming due.
I went completely ballistic creatively.
I designed packaging, custom graphics, paper bags, labels, booklets, and countless other things that would eventually become part of goodsugar.
I also wrote an entire book during COVID called The goodsugar Diet. It’s really good, and I encourage you to check it out.
The book is based on my personal experience with food addiction and anxiety. It presents nutrition from a relatively simple perspective, much of which was handed down to me by my food mentor, Fred Bisci.
I wanted goodsugar to represent something very specific.
Delicious food made from organic, plant-based ingredients. No unnecessary junk. No single-use plastic packaging. No ridiculous compromises that undermine the very reasons people are trying to eat better in the first place.
And I wanted the business to be beautiful, organized, clean, and consistent.
I wasn’t going to build something just to get big. I wanted to build something worth getting big.
Two extraordinary people came with me from Juice Press.
Peter K., who was effectively our COO and real CFO, came aboard, bringing years of operational and financial experience.
And Naomi Morales, who had managed what I considered the best-performing store at Juice Press, joined us as well.
The three of us have been working on goodsugar together for approximately four years now.
We’ve spent these years developing the products, refining our systems, building the team, and creating the kind of store that we believe deserves to exist.
And now we’re getting ready for the next chapter.
We’re going after store number two.

We have a particular space in our sights, and negotiations are underway.
I’m not going to tell you where it is just yet. Anyone who has spent time in retail real estate knows that you never count your chickens before they hatch. Until a deal is signed, nothing is guaranteed.
But I feel more optimistic about the next couple of years than I have in a very long time.
And that optimism has a lot to do with our customers.
We have developed an extraordinarily supportive, loyal customer base. They love what we do, and I believe that loyalty comes from the things we give them in return.
They want delicious food.
They want healthy food.
They want organic ingredients.
They don’t want everything they eat and drink packaged in plastic.
They want to support businesses whose values are reflected in their daily operations, not just printed on a wall somewhere.
And they want consistency. When they find something they love, they want to come back tomorrow and have it be just as good as it was yesterday.
That is the relationship we are building.
It’s a wonderful relationship, and I can speak on behalf of our entire team when I say that we take it very, very seriously.
Every single day.
You can see it in how meticulously we maintain our store, how carefully we prepare our products, and how much attention we give to the little details that most people might not even consciously notice.
Those details are everything.
I come from three generations of retail experience, and one of the things I’ve learned is that you cannot fake a great retail business for very long. Eventually, customers figure out whether you genuinely care.
And we care.
We have big plans for goodsugar. I would love to see our stores in many different neighborhoods and eventually in many different cities. But I also know that every great retail business has to begin with getting the fundamentals right.
One store at a time.
One customer at a time.
One product at a time.
I still think about that little store on East 1st Street, and how my first thought was that having a store might help me make lots of friends.
Sixteen years later, I realize that wasn’t such a bad reason to start a business.
Because in a way, that’s exactly what we’re doing at goodsugar.
We’re making friends, serving them food we believe in, and building something together.
Stay tuned. We’re just getting started.
tap into our thousands of self-help blogs,



talk back